Star Wars...
yep, I'm a fan, or was a fan... Saw the latest, Episode III, Revenge of the Script Writer. What's happened over the last few years that its now become fashionable to roll your eyes at these movies? As a kid I could spout dialogue from Han and Obi-wan and Luke and Yoda in my sleep...okay I can STILL spout dialogue from Han and Obi-wan and Luke and Yoda, but that's besides the point. It was dialogue like:
Obi-wan: "Vader was seduced by the dark side of the force."
Luke: "The force?"
Obi-wan: "The force is what gives a Jedi his power. It is an energy field, created by all living things. It surrounds us and penetrates us, it binds the galaxy together."
Contrasted with dialogue from Episode III...
"Hold me Annakin, hold me like you did on Naboo!" and the perplexing
"I love you!"--"No, I love you!"--"No, I love you more!" banter between Padme and the nascent Vader. I laughed at that one--and felt ashamed to have laughed at Star Wars--but of course that set the guy in the seat next to me laughing, and then others. The guy's wife promptly smacked him in the arm.
And of course, the Movie Reviewers' ink-blot viewings all came out the same on the political front. They looked at Palpatine and Vader and saw George Bush. Is the political message there?--only if you want it to be, as the movie reviewers did. The movie has so many contradictions in it it's hard to take any political message seriously.
Vader: "You're either with me or my enemy."
Obi-wan: "Only the Sith deal in absolutes."
So I guess John Kerry led the Jedi Council, for his nuance allowed them to see EVERYTHING in...black and white. Either you follow the Jedi order or you're out, all other paths lead to the dark side, and the bad guys wear black outfits. Lucas doesn't have nuance in him--and neither do fairy tales. They always tell a moral. Remember, "A long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away..." sounds a little like "Once upon a time..." Right?
Anyway, if one REALLY wanted to insert a political message, you could liken Palpatine to Hitler, or...if you wanted to show a parallel between democracy in wartime...to FDR. Think about it.
Depression, national crisis...enacted broad sweeping new laws, Social security, welfare, government works projects...all social programs to consolidate federal power, the same ones that are dragging the US down today. Then came the war. (some crazies even suggest that FDR knew Pearl Harbor was going to happen--I DO NOT. But it was a national crisis, took no time at all to declare war.) Huge expanded war powers, INTERNMENT...(let that one soak in for a second...he put Japanese people in camps, in the US. Gitmo is a walk in the park next to that one.), he was in office longer than any other President, built the Death Star--I mean the atomic bomb... Anyone else seeing the parallel here? Anyone? *crickets*
So maybe Lucas is right...depending on your point of view...
Obi-wan: "Luke, you're going to find that many of the truths we cling to depend mostly on our own point of view."Maybe that's the true genius of Star Wars...everybody is entertained.